Game show buzzer delayed light output

I recently bought a makey makey and am using it to do a family feud style. I have two buzzers and i have got them to light up upon being pressed in. I was wanting to make it where the first one hit only lights up rather than both and it stays lit for 5 seconds. Even if you would know of a resource that would be able to give me direction in this that would be awesome.

Well, program it to do what you want…