Raspberry Pi Pico 2 W booting continuously into BOOTSEL

I recently bought a few Raspberry Pico 2 W’s. They have been working great, but lately, in a project of mine, one of the pico’s stopped working so I replaced it and kept going. T
he Pico in question is having an issue where it is always booting into BOOTSEL (showing up as a mass storage media device every time).

Things I have tested:
The BOOTSEL button with a multimeter (it is working fine)
Shorting the run pin (resets, but connects again in BOOTSEL)
Multiple different USB cables (Other pico 2’s work fine on same cable and computer)
UF2 Nuke

Was looking for help regarding diagnosing and fixing or seeing if the board is faulty.

Thanks!

Odd. Have you tried swapping SD cards? Reboot PC as well…and ensure only one is connected at once