Steel:
If you don’t like me then stay off my internetz?
I finally found where you quoted that from, I thought it sounded familiar, as it turns out I did write it.
Any reason for replying to a post made over 8 months ago?
Steel:
I think they are completely free to post in a forum owned by an electronics company under “PCB Deal Details”.
You yourself posted a quote from Phoenix, which although is not a direct ‘competitor’ of batchpcb…by your standards doesn’t belong here as it is not a sparkfun entity.
Sparkfun themselves said (quite a while ago), that the idea of BatchPCB was to prototype boards, and then once you finish prototyping with them, to do your production through GPX. This is/was why Sparkfun got GPX to do annoying/small/ever-changing panels, something they otherwise wouldn't do. There also is/was a 5% kickback that SFE got from your direct GPX order, if you mentioned that you prototyped your boards with BatchPCB. It is/was GPX's way of getting larger orders, to make the smaller BatchPCB ones worthwhile.
My point is, that GPX is not a competitor but actually like a big brother of the BatchPCB service, in that GPX hopes to ‘hook’ a few large run’s after people see how nice their BatchPCB boards are.
So ‘by my standards’, after your little history lesson, you will see that it is ‘allowed’ here.
Steel:
Let them post their deals. This forum is a place to learn, and if somebody does come up with a better deal, then I sure as crap want to know…and it would be pretty silly if these things were sensored.
The problem is that they spam, and their deals have never been very good value. They are trying to catch out people who are new to all this and who know no better. Myself and a few other forums members are constantly posting in these threads that come up, showing how they are NOT good deals for people. Another member has a PCB that he posts in all these threads, and asks for a quote, same board, different manufacturers. Not once has a good price ever been given.
Steel:
This forum is PCB Deal details. Not “BatchPCB service”. Unless Sparkfun wants to change that, then it is an open forum…perhaps the guidelines are not clear? Maybe.
By what logic is this? The tagline to this forum is "Questions about the BatchPCB service", so it is exactly what you said it's not.
Steel:
…But until this has been defined, I think it is great for PCB manufacturers to offer up their ‘offers’ so that I can choose who is going to meet my needs most. Although I agree with you that nobody has beat phoenix in this capacity, it still should not stand to dump out all other pcb deals…
It has been defined, read the index page of the forums, it's written there.
Steel:
Unless Sparkfun makes this particular forum for just batchpcb customers.
Again. They have, this is it.